The best in Ohio's abandoned buildings, weird history, and restless spirits!


Mater Dolorosa Cemetery

One of the most interesting, and eerie, cemeteries in this region. Hidden within the Cuyahoga Valley National Park just east of Peninsula, this abandoned Irish cemetery lies sequestered within the woods adjacent to the Happy Days Visitor Center on Route 303.

Established in 1869 as the burial ground for the Mother of Sorrows (“Mater Dolorosa”) Catholic Church, This very old cemetery attained a certain local status as belonging to an infamous “Satanic Church” in Peninsula. Before the church it was a tiny family plot belonging to Irish farmers, John and Mary Ann Doud, who left it to the First Bishop of Cleveland, who in turn gave it to the Mother of Sorrows Church. It’s hard to know when this essentially unremarkable Catholic church got its reputation as “satanic,” but the churchyard it left behind is constantly plagued by mysterious white figures of unknown origin.

A view of the gated Cassidy Family plot.

The cemetery seems large for its size – approximately 11 to 13 headstones. In actuality, at least 23 persons are known to be buried here. Upon a review of historical records, at least 5 graves remain unaccounted for.




Sources and Related Links

1 Comment

  1. Terez Cassidy Storm

    The Cassidy monument at Mater Dolorosa Cemetery inscribed “Cassidy” is the graves of Margaret Glancey Cassidy & her second husband Patrick Cassidy. The Cassidy family emigrated from Inver, County Donegal, Ireland, first to Canada in from 1833 to 1834and then on to Peninsula, Summit County Ohio where the family purchased over 300 acres of farmland. There were 3 brothers: Patrick Cassidy (1804-1885), Thomas Cassidy (1812–1902), James Cassidy, II (1809-1841) and his wife Margeret Glancey (1812-1885). James Cassidy, II was killed felling trees while clearing the farmland. He and Margaret Glancey Cassidy had 4 children: John C Cassidy (1832–1885), Mary Cassidy (1833–1880), James C. Cassidy III, (1837–1909) and William H Cassidy (1837–1925). In 1842 the widow Margaret Glancey Cassidy married Patrick Cassidy, the brother of James. Margaret Glancey Cassidy and Patrick Cassidy had 5 children: Andrew R Cassidy (1842–1920), Hugh H Cassidy
    (1846–1913), Catherine “Kate” Cassidy (1846–1924), Agnes Cassidy (1849–?) and
    Anna Marie Cassidy (1854–1922). In the 190 years after the Cassidys’ arrival in NE Ohio there have been 7 generations of decedents born, many of whom still reside in NE Ohio and others have relocated and reside in other States in the US.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.